Functional vs Non-Functional Requirements in Engineering

What Are Functional Requirements?

In software engineering, functional requirements define what a system is supposed to do. These are the specific features or capabilities that software must have to meet the user's needs. Functional requirements are generally expressed in terms of:

• User actions: Describing how users interact with the system, such as logging in, submitting forms, or accessing reports.
• System behavior: Outlining how the system should respond to certain inputs or triggers, including tasks like data processing, database management, and interactions with other systems.

Functional requirements often form the foundation of a project, as they dictate the core functions that the system must perform to achieve its business objectives. For companies offering custom software engineering services, ensuring that functional requirements are well-defined is key to delivering a successful solution that meets the client’s needs.

‍

Examples of Functional Requirements:

• User authentication system with email and password login
• Real-time data updates across multiple devices
• File upload capabilities with file size restrictions

‍

What Are Non-Functional Requirements?

While functional requirements define what the system should do, non-functional requirements focus on how the system performs those tasks. These requirements are equally crucial as they directly impact the user experience and system quality.

Non-functional requirements deal with aspects such as:

• Performance: How fast should the system respond under various conditions?
• Security: What measures must be in place to protect sensitive data?
• Scalability: Can the system handle increased user loads as the business grows?
• Usability: How easy is it for users to navigate and interact with the system?

In many cases, non-functional requirements ensure that the software operates smoothly in the real world, addressing concerns such as system downtime, security vulnerabilities, and user frustration.

‍

Examples of Non-Functional Requirements:

• System must respond to user input within 2 seconds under normal load
• Data must be encrypted in transit and at rest
• The system should be able to scale up to 10,000 concurrent users without degradation in performance

‍

Key Differences Between Functional and Non-Functional Requirements

Understanding the distinction between these two types of requirements is critical for software engineering teams. While both are necessary for a successful project, they serve different purposes and must be handled differently during development.

‍

Purpose:

• Functional requirements describe what the system must do (features, actions, processes).
• Non-functional requirements define how the system must perform (performance, security, scalability).

‍Focus:

• Functional requirements focus on business objectives and user needs.
• Non-functional requirements focus on system quality and user experience.

Measurement:

• Functional requirements are often measured by specific test cases (e.g., verifying that a feature works as expected).
• Non-functional requirements are measured through performance metrics (e.g., response time, system uptime, or security compliance).

‍

Balancing Functional and Non-Functional Requirements

In any software project, both functional and non-functional requirements play a crucial role. However, prioritizing one over the other depends on the project’s goals, client needs, and technical constraints.

‍

When to Prioritize Functional Requirements

In the early stages of a project, functional requirements usually take center stage. Without clear definitions of what the software should do, it's impossible to build a working solution. Projects that focus heavily on user-facing features, like e-commerce platforms or mobile apps, typically prioritize functional requirements. For example:

• E-commerce platform: Functional requirements may include product search, shopping cart management, and payment processing.
• Custom software engineering services: Functional requirements might include specific workflows or integrations with third-party systems.

‍

When to Prioritize Non-Functional Requirements

Non-functional requirements often become a priority when the project moves beyond the MVP (minimum viable product) stage or when scaling becomes necessary. For projects where system performance, security, and reliability are crucial, non-functional requirements take precedence. For example:

• Banking application: Non-functional requirements around security and performance are paramount to prevent data breaches and ensure smooth user experience during high-traffic periods.
• SaaS platforms: Scalability is a top priority, especially for platforms that anticipate rapid user growth and must ensure system stability under load.

Common Challenges with Non-Functional Requirements

Non-functional requirements are often more difficult to define and test compared to functional requirements. They may also require more technical expertise to implement and optimize. Here are some common challenges:

• Ambiguity: Non-functional requirements, such as "the system should be easy to use," can be too vague to implement effectively. It's important to define clear, measurable benchmarks for requirements like usability or performance.
• Testing Complexity: Verifying non-functional requirements often requires specialized testing environments or tools. For instance, testing for scalability might involve simulating thousands of users to see how the system performs under load.
• Resource Constraints: Optimizing for non-functional requirements, especially performance or security, can demand significant development resources. Developers must balance these optimizations with other project constraints like deadlines and budgets.

‍

How Functional and Non-Functional Requirements Impact the Software Development Process

The development process for software engineering teams should always involve balancing both functional and non-functional requirements. However, the way these two types of requirements influence different stages of development varies:

‍

1. Requirement Gathering

In the requirement-gathering phase, functional requirements are often discussed first. They provide a clear roadmap for the software’s capabilities. However, non-functional requirements must also be captured at this stage, particularly if they influence architecture decisions.

‍

For example, if high performance is a non-functional requirement, the team may choose a particular tech stack or infrastructure to support it from the beginning.

‍

2. Design and Architecture

During the design phase, functional requirements influence user interface (UI) and experience (UX) design. Non-functional requirements, on the other hand, guide decisions around the architecture of the system, such as whether a microservices architecture is needed to ensure scalability.

‍

3. Development

Functional requirements translate into specific code and features. Developers implement these requirements to build the desired functionality. Meanwhile, non-functional requirements, like security and performance, may require additional steps, such as optimizing queries, securing APIs, or fine-tuning system resources.

‍

4. Testing

Functional testing ensures that the system works as expected based on defined use cases. This is typically done using unit tests and integration tests. For non-functional requirements, testing is often more complex and requires performance testing, security audits, and load testing to ensure the system performs as required.

‍

Real-World Example: Prioritizing Requirements in an E-commerce Platform

Let’s explore how both functional and non-functional requirements would apply to an e-commerce platform:

‍

Functional Requirements:

• User should be able to search for products by name, category, or brand.
• System should enable users to create accounts, add items to their cart, and proceed with secure payments.

Non-Functional Requirements:

• The site should load within 2 seconds for users accessing from North America.
• All user data, including payment details, must be encrypted during transit and storage.
• The system must be able to scale to accommodate high traffic during peak shopping seasons, such as Black Friday.

Both types of requirements are critical for the success of the platform, but they serve different purposes. Functional requirements ensure that users can complete their shopping journey, while non-functional requirements guarantee that the journey is fast, secure, and scalable.

‍

Defining Success with Both Requirement Types

For any successful software project, both functional and non-functional requirements must be clearly defined and balanced. Functional requirements drive the core functionality of the system, while non-functional requirements ensure that the software performs well in real-world scenarios.

In the highly competitive U.S. software market, optimizing both types of requirements is essential for delivering robust, scalable, and high-performing software solutions. Businesses seeking custom software engineering services must collaborate with development teams to ensure that all requirements, functional and non-functional, are properly addressed.

‍